Well, I can't exactly get all technical like you did because honestly, I don't mess around with my video cards very much (if ever), but I would say that I favor Nvidia more simply because I've had 3 Nvidia cards that I've never had technical problems with while I've had 4 ATI cards, all of which I've had problems with. My ATI X800, that I ended up paying $500 for, melted less than a year after I bought it; I replaced it with an X700 and within a year it was on the verge of failing and having similar visual issues as the X800 did. Then I had dual X1600s running crossfire (when it worked without crashing my computer); they still work after a couple years but I think the fans are failing. The crossfire worked for a few months after I had them then after a driver update, crossfire wouldn't turn back on until a handful of driver updates and a couple years later. My Nvidia cards, two of which were integrating, ran just fine for the purposes that I used them for and I never even had any issue with updating drivers as I repeatedly did with my X800, X700 and X1600s (the final of which needed a windows reinstall to fix). And now I have an iMac, so obviously I don't (well didn't when I bought mine) have a choice. Even then though, I can't run Crysis on high or anything with it, but I probably couldn't get away with it with that single ATI HD 4850 or w/e it is either, and that doesn't really bother me much because it's been almost two months since I've played a game that needed that much power. Photoshop and everything I use on OS X has no issues with Nvidia and the previous failures I've had with ATI kind of steers me away from them unless I was really in need the power like lets say for Crysis. I must say though about Nvidia though, I do have a control center on my Bootcamped version of Windows that allows me to force AA and control quality vs. performance and some advanced options that I don't dare touch for fear of killing my logic board and having to pay $1100 to replace it, but I have no control center of any kind on OS X; however, I don't really need to force AA or anything like that, so it doesn't matter that much, I suppose.